Yield Maintenance vs. Defeasance
If your commercial loan documents mention prepayment restrictions, there’s a good chance you’ll see one of these two terms – and they’re often confused because both exist for the same underlying reason: protecting the lender’s expected yield. But operationally and financially, they’re quite different. Here’s how to tell them apart and estimate which one will cost you more.
Quick Comparison
| Yield Maintenance | Defeasance | |
|---|---|---|
| What you pay | A calculated cash penalty | The cost of a securities portfolio (usually Treasuries) |
| Who holds the loan after | Loan is paid off and closed | Loan stays open; a successor borrower takes it over |
| Complexity | Relatively simple – one calculation | Complex – legal entity formation, securities purchase, servicer/rating agency review |
| Typical timeline | Can close in days | Often takes 30–45+ days to arrange |
| Typical cost | Moderate to high | Often higher, due to added transaction costs |
| Common on | CMBS loans, life company loans, bank CRE loans | Primarily CMBS (securitized) loans |
How Yield Maintenance Works (Recap)
With yield maintenance, you pay off the loan directly and write a check for the penalty. The penalty is calculated by discounting your remaining scheduled payments at a current replacement yield (typically a Treasury rate) and comparing that to your outstanding balance – the difference is what you owe.
The loan is then fully closed. No new entity, no ongoing obligations, no successor borrower. Once you’ve paid the balance plus the penalty, you’re done.
👉 See the exact math: Yield Maintenance Formula Explained
How Defeasance Works
Defeasance doesn’t pay off the loan in the traditional sense – instead:
- You (the borrower) purchase a portfolio of securities – almost always U.S. Treasuries or agency securities – structured so their cash flows exactly match your loan’s remaining scheduled payments.
- Those securities are pledged as collateral, replacing the real estate as security for the loan.
- A successor borrower (typically a special-purpose entity provided by a defeasance consulting firm) legally takes over the loan obligation.
- Your original property is released from the lien, free and clear, and you can sell or refinance it.
- The loan technically stays outstanding – on paper – collateralized entirely by the securities portfolio, until its original maturity date.
This is significantly more involved than yield maintenance, which is why defeasance transactions typically require specialized consultants, legal counsel, rating agency confirmation (for CMBS loans), and several weeks of lead time.
Which One Costs More?
There’s no universal rule, but defeasance is often, though not always, the more expensive option, for a few structural reasons:
- Securities cost more than the pure interest-rate math implies. You’re buying actual Treasury securities at market prices, which include transaction costs and don’t always align perfectly with the exact cash flow schedule needed – often requiring slightly more principal than a yield maintenance calculation would produce.
- Transaction costs stack on top. Legal fees, defeasance consultant fees, successor borrower fees, rating agency fees, and accountant fees are common – often totaling $50,000–$150,000+ depending on loan size and complexity, on top of the securities cost itself.
- Timing risk. Because defeasance takes weeks to arrange, securities must be purchased at prevailing rates on the actual closing date – if rates move against you during that window, costs can shift.
Yield maintenance, by contrast, is a single calculated number with no added transaction layer – which is one reason many borrowers view it as the simpler (and often cheaper) of the two when their loan documents permit it.
Why CMBS Loans Often Use Defeasance
CMBS (Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities) loans are pooled together and sold to bond investors as a fixed income stream. If a borrower could simply pay off their loan early for cash, the bondholders would face prepayment risk – getting their principal back early and having to reinvest at potentially lower rates, with no mechanism to keep the pool’s promised cash flows intact.
Defeasance solves this by keeping the loan technically alive: the securities substituted as collateral continue generating the exact same cash flows the bondholders were promised, all the way to the original maturity date. That’s why defeasance, not yield maintenance, is the default in most CMBS loan documents – even though yield maintenance is simpler for the borrower.
Which Should You Expect on Your Loan?
- Bank commercial loan? Almost certainly yield maintenance (or a simple step-down penalty) – banks rarely use defeasance.
- Life insurance company loan? Usually yield maintenance.
- CMBS (securitized) loan? Very likely defeasance – check your note carefully, as some CMBS loans do use yield maintenance instead, especially in the final years before maturity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a loan switch from defeasance to yield maintenance, or vice versa?
No – the prepayment structure is fixed in your original loan documents and can’t be swapped later.
Is defeasance ever cheaper than yield maintenance?
It can be in certain rate environments or loan structures, but it’s less common – added transaction costs typically outweigh any savings.
How long does defeasance typically take to complete?
Commonly 30-45 days from engaging a defeasance consultant to closing, depending on loan complexity and rating agency requirements.
Do I need a specialist to handle defeasance?
Yes, in virtually all cases – borrowers almost always engage a dedicated defeasance consulting firm and legal counsel.